Friday, July 20, 2012

The Dark Knight Rises – Dark, Knightly and Rises Up to Expectations


Director: Christopher Nolan
Actors: Christian Bale, Michael Caine, Gary Oldman, Tom Hardy
Rating: 4/5

Once in every few years, a films expectation reaches fever pitch. Yet, only a handful ever have lived up to it. The last in the Batman Trilogy, to the delight of fans, does. That it does so while continuing on the same themes it addressed before, is a feather hardly any film franchisee has claimed. 

Seven years since Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale) retired Batman, a new villain Bane (Tom Hardy) threatens not only Gotham’s peace but its very existence. When the entire city is taken hostage by Bane’s men and the police are locked up, Batman must return, and fight an impossible resistance with a handful others.

The least one expects from a very popular, self-professed end of a series film is a grand scale. Most commercial cinema merely increases the effects and physical action. While Nolan indeed delivers on these, he goes beyond.

A bank or even a building being held hostage is well known in cinema. Did you ever imagine an entire city held hostage for months? Like in the second part of the series, Nolan then asks the question: would normal citizens rise up to become heroes?

Yet, morally and metaphorically, ‘The Dark Knight’ was stronger. There he asked the same question, but to individual citizens and in the climax on the two boats, to an opposite group of people. There, Batman wins because people in the two boats beat their instinct for self survival by refusing to kill the others for their own sake. In that scene, everyone becomes a superhero. Everyone becomes Batman.

That edginess of script, that triumph of true courage, is missing in this part. It compensates by rising on other counts.

The Nolan brothers (Christopher and Jonathan) know how to intermix a grim story of power, corruption, control and heroism with a spectacular razzle-dazzle. In a very powerful screenplay the brothers bring attention to the corruption, the power structures and the chaos of the affluent class.

And the brothers, in creating villains that are alter-egos of Batman, and in often giving them ideals as high as him but in the end showing these anarchist villains failing, perhaps makes the greatest joke, the greatest metaphor on the state of the world today.

Perhaps the hidden, dark message is that no matter how much one resists – be it Batman or his villains, a corrupt power structure and affluence, will survive. The brothers perhaps want to say that resistance, eventually, proves futile. Perhaps they want to say the opposite, that good and bad, light and darkness and falling and rising take turns and that no matter what, one has to resist.   

Nolan is a man in absolute control of his craft. You’ll be hard pressed to find a man with such an ability to interplay sound and visuals to create a three dimensional vision in your head.

Hans Zimmer assist him with superlative yet gentle and sombre background score while as expected, the special effects division delivers the wares without going overboard.

Nolan carries forward the themes from the previous two films, fear, death, anger, corruption, heroism and chaos and rounds them up into a perfect whole.

In the end though, the true hero that rises from this series is Christopher Nolan. In the wasteland of commercial Hollywood cinema, he is the best thing that has happened in a long long time. May his clan increase everywhere. 

(This review was written for the wire service, IANS)

Saturday, July 14, 2012

The Intouchables – Must Touch & Feel


Director: Olivier Nakache, Eric Toledano
Actors: Omar Sy, François Cluzet
Rating: 4/5

What comes to mind when you think disability? Sadness, pity and charity? And what comes to mind when you think disability films? Same? If that’s the case, ‘The Intouchables’ – the story of a man paralysed from the neck down and his helper, will surprise you with its wit, humour, fun and zest for life.

Driss (Omar Sy) goes for an interview as a helper for a paraplegic person only to get unemployment benefits. His acerbic frankness wins the heart of the disabled person Philippe (François Cluzet) who hires him against better advice.

The two form an unlikely pair, one physically disabled, the other socially; one morose the other full of life; one with the money to do everything but not the limbs, the other with the limbs and life but no money or social standing; one white the other black.

As they touch each others life, in a fun, poignant manner they change forever, becoming more the men than they ever though possible.
Can disability be fun?

The two things that will win your heart in the film, is its witty humour and the chemistry of the lead pair. Rarely in cinema have two actors been so different and yet their pairing been so perfect, and their timing so immaculate.

Omar Sy as the black man from a Parisian ghetto is a revelation while veteran actor François Cluzet delivers a punchy performance.

The Intouchables is a very important film in the history of cinema, because it is one of the rare instances where a film about a person with disability does not rely on pathos, melodrama and pity. The writer/director pair of Olivier Nakache and Eric Toledano handle this true story of an actual odd couple with a dignity, sensitivity and humour rare in cinema. 

It becomes and important film because it explores a hitherto rarely explored dimension of disability i.e. the life and living of people with disability and not their sadness. Yes it is sad they are disabled, but it is in no way pathetic and no way does it mean that life ends where disability begins. Indeed, many disabled people claim today – to the utter surprise and horror of ‘normal’ people – that for many of them life actually began after their disability.  

Thus in showing that the most precious commodity in life is not necessarily the use of limbs, but a positive frame of mind, friends and laughter, it becomes a great, funny, poignant and uplifting film. Don’t miss it for the world. 

(This review has been written for the wire service, IANS)

Friday, June 29, 2012

The Amazing Spiderman – Poorly Executed Reboot


Director: Marc Webb
Actors: Andrew Garfield, Emma Stone, Rhys Ifans
Rating: 2.5/5

There is a similarity between the tribals of Chhattisgarh and the studio that has produced ‘The Amazing Spiderman’ (TAS). Both seem to be desperately battling for survival. What else would explain the reboot of a franchise that began hardly a decade back and which, despite its best intentions has only regressed the original story?

The all too familiar story of Spiderman’s beginnings has undergone only cosmetic changes. His father is shown to have been working for Oscorp before he disappeared. His girlfriend is Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone) who is his first love in the comic books and not Mary Jane and her father is a cop. Spiderman inadvertently creates the monster he later fights. And Peter Parker/Spiderman (Andrew Garfield) lets both his girlfriend and her father know his secret identity.
The really amazing thing about this film is that this almost similar film to the 2002 version even got made...
 It is hence fun finding out why this film was made. Here are six probable reasons.

1. Peter Parker in the original franchisee got married and it was time to send him back to school. 2. If comic books can reboot from a Spiderman to ‘The Amazing Spiderman’, why can’t a film. 3. To help the Titanic of a sinking studio, stay afloat.

4. If kids can like Transformers, they will like anything that has special effects. 5. Girls hate lizards so every time the lizard guy comes up, girls will jump on the lap of their boyfriends who will create a word of mouth buzz. 6. The studio found a director whose last name was had some connection with spiders - Webb.

At its core level, one can describe this film as the template of the original Spiderman mixed with few scattered elements taken from various films. E.g. introduction of the concerned father of the girlfriend like in Twilight or have him make his own gadgets like Batman.

There are too many problems with the film to narrate. First is the story itself which does not have the emotional pull or the engagement of the original Spiderman. The characterisations are not handled properly and even Gwen ends up becoming just a pretty face without a mind or aspiration of her own.

Even the hesitant, love angle between Peter Parker and Gwen is not handled well. And many characters are left hanging without a conclusion, most notably that of Irrfan Khan. Despite being a brilliant actor he is hardly suited for this blink-and-miss role where he fumbles with his ascent.

One department where TAS does not fail, is its special effects. Considering the state of commercial cinema emanating from Hollywood, one can safely assume that this would be reason enough for the film to make a billion dollars globally.

TAS gets an early release in India. It is not hard to imagine why. Demographically India not only has the world’s largest number of teens, but also the worlds largest concentration of them, teens who have grown up ‘loving’ the brainless ‘Transformers’ series. The Indian angle with the presumably last minute introduction of Irfaan Khan is also meant to woo Indian audiences.

If reboot is what Hollywood was looking for, they could have done something much more interesting and fun. Maybe a kind of handheld camera, found footage film like you had in the underappreciated gem ‘Chronicle’ last year.

If quick reboot is the new flavour of Hollywood, one dreads to wonder what they will reboot next - Harry Potter and Twilight?

(This review was written for the wire service IANS)

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Supermen of Malegaon – Poignant, Hilarious Ode To Filmmaking


Director: Faiza Ahmad Khan
Cast: Sheikh Nasir, Akram Khan, Shafique, Farogh Jafri
Rating: 4.5/5

There is global cinema and national cinema. In a country like India, there’s also regional cinema. What many don’t know is that India is also home to what can be called ‘Local Cinema’ where film are produced and consumed locally.

‘Supermen of Malegaon’ is a hilarious, poignant and well-researched take on one of the dozens of local film industries existing in India.

It is a love poem to cinema, an ode to the spirit of human ingenuity, a passionate tale about making films and it’s hilarious to boot. For most of the audience, this might be the funniest documentary ever made.

A film crew follows Sheikh Nasir a resident of Malegaon as he tries to make a parody of Superman called ‘Malegaon Ka Superman’ with actors, cast, technicians and props sourced from his town. We get a glimpse of the joys, the agony, the achievement and the epiphany of creating cinema.

That he is making a low budget, made for a local audience film without the aspiration of making money, lends it the poignancy and innocence missing from the biggest filmmaking centres of the world.

If Marin Scorsese’s ‘Hugo’ was the feature film version of the depiction of one man’s passion for making special effects laden cinema, SOM is the documentary version of the same passion.

Like Georges Méliès who desired to make a rocket fly and men disappear at a time when it was considered impossible, Sheikh Nasir tries to find cheap alternative to making superman fly, to find local solutions to complex cinematic problems at a budget where such special effects seem impossible.

SOM is thus a study in ingenuity, of a die-hard but untrained film crew’s intense desire and ability to conjure up tricks to create magic on screen. Thus we see Sheikh locally making the green chrome background used for special effects.

We see our crew tear up our Superman’s external undergarment and another mans jeans to hoist them, groins first, through an iron bar before the green chrome screen to show them flying. We see Sheikh using a cycle as a trolley and an empty bullock cart as a jimmy jib.

While it is a serious film about someone making a parody, it also becomes a metaphoric parody of commercial cinema, and all the clichés they belt out in a spirit of self-righteous megalomania.

For this is how filmmaking can and should be – a work of passion first and commercial considerations second, just like Georges Méliès and Sheikh Nasir saw and like thousands of aspiring filmmakers globally dream of but are not allowed to make.

Ironically, this tale of Malegaon’s filmmaking ‘Supermen’ has been made by a motley group of talented superwomen. Director Faiza Ahmad Khan’s keen sense of satire and irony are amply visible. Sneha Khanwalkar (Oye Lucky, Lucky Oye, Gangs Of Wasseypur) gives a rustic feel to the film with her earthen music while editor Shweta Venkat Matthew lends the film its poignancy with her observant edits.

Two superhero films release this week in India - SOM and ‘The Amazing Spiderman – The Untold Story’. Ironically it is SOM that has an amazing story that has not yet been told. Spiderman the world has watched on three previous occasions but this is perhaps the first time anyone is telling the funny, hugely inspiring and globally awarded story of a local film industry.

The choice of what to watch, dear viewer, is entirely yours. 

(This review has been written for the wire service IANS)

Friday, June 15, 2012

Kshay – Small Film, Big Message


Director: Karan Gour
Actors: Rasika Dugal, Alekh Sangal
Rating: 3.5/5

Digital filmmaking has opened up a whole universe of opportunity for those with cinematic aspirations. Today, like photography being the art of the masses, filmmaking has come closer home to the larger masses.

This should have resulted in crazy, wonderful experiments. And it has. To have proof watch independent film ‘Kshay’, made on a micro-budget, a handful of actors and over a two years period. It is a film which despite its flaws, not only manages to hold its own, but in a few moments, shines.

Chhaya (Rasika Dugal) gets enamoured by a white statue of goddess Laxmi and wants to have it at any cost. The husband, who is struggling to make ends meet, agrees to get it once he has money. Soon however her desire takes an obsessive turn to disastrous consequences.
A tale of obsession...

The greatest strength of the film, is its obvious but beautiful and extremely important metaphor. Chhaya’s obsession for the statue of Laxmi (goddess of wealth) and her ability to see it everywhere is an allegory to modern man’s maddening obsession for wealth. Driven by a madness not different from Chhaya’s, we want money. We do not care what this does to those near us or what its final conclusion would be.

Like the mythical king of greed who banished by a just king asks for refuge in the metal gold and is granted only to finally pollute the king because the king wears a golden crown, we have all been corrupted by the need of something more than that we can possibly consume in our lifetimes. And this obsession, debutante director/writer Karan Gour captures beautifully and metaphorically in his film.

The film shot in black and white, complements its straightforward statement against obsession. There’s no final reason given for the character’s fixation with the statue, but there really is no need. Obsession is an end in itself, an end of all beauty and grace.

The film however is not bereft of flaws. Though otherwise the editing is nice, it is 15 minutes too long. One has the nagging feeling that the makers were scared of not being taken too seriously if the film did not reach 90 minutes duration. This leads an otherwise beautiful film to slack.

Many shots are useless and don’t add to the narrative. E.g. in the end when the guy is crossing the road, it takes him forever and the camera meanders with the character. It does not serve any purpose because his next crucial act is not carried out in that one long take. Three minutes could have been easily saved just in that shot.

The film rests on the petite shoulders of Rasika Dugal. And this FTII graduate plays the transformation of an innocent, loving housewife into a bewitched woman elegantly. One can only wish her the best, hoping she’d catch the attention of more filmmakers for her solid performance.

It is simply amazing what a person with a sound knowledge of the art and craft of filmmaking can do today, without even going to film school and with often as much budget as it takes to buy the world’s cheapest car. The budget can be ‘nano’ but the film can really be big.

It is an exciting time indeed in India, to be a viewer full of aspirtation - for seek, and ye shall find the film of your seeking. 

(This review has been written for the wire service IANS)

Rock of Ages – Funniest Rock Comedy Since Spinal Tap


Director: Adam Shankman
Actors: Julianne Hough, Diego Boneta, Tom Cruise
Rating: 4/5

If you have been following the news lately, you’d have heard of ACP Vasant Dhoble. The ‘Dabaang’ cop is wreaking havoc on Mumbai’s already depleting night life by landing unannounced at parties armed with hockey stick, camera or an entire police battalion.

Dhoble has an enemy now – ‘Rock of Ages’ that takes off from where Dhoble’s vigilantism begins to deliver the funniest rock film since ‘This Is Spinal Tap’.

After his live music joint is threatened by moral police led by Patricia (Catherine Zeta-Jones) Dennis (Alec Baldwin) must find ways to save it. Hope comes in the form of Stacee Jaxx (Tom Cruise) the popular rocker going solo and his own waiter Drew (Diego Boneta) who is inspired by his singer girl friend Sherrie (Julianne Hough) to have rock dreams of his own. Things however, will take a turn for the worse. 

Tom Cruise is simply hilarious as the ageing rocker with a sense of self-persecution

If one were to look at this as a simply ‘Rock and Roll’ movie, one is bound to be disappointed. For one the songs in the film are not all rock and roll with generous dosage of pop, love ballads and a slight sprinkling of the blues.

However, look at the film as a farce, a satire on everything including rock and roll, and you’re on hilarious ground hardly ever traversed so well after ‘This Is Spinal Tap’ captured the imagination of the masses.

In the true essence of a farcical comedy this musical based on a Broadway musical directed by Kristin Hanggi with a book by Chris D'Arienzo, mocks rock and roll and its icons and their self indulgence. Thus Tom Cruise’s serious rocker act becomes a spoof on all rockers, and their over indulgence on sex and alcohol and their hilarious sense of persecution when they were all along enjoying life.  

The serious journalist from Rolling Stones magazine who almost ends up having sex with an ageing rocker she seems to hate, is a spoof on all ‘serious’ rock and roll journalists. Its tacit message: don’t burden music like rock and roll with too much of meaning. Enjoy it and forget it.

The films irreverence to the same things it seems to be valorising is its funniest gig.

Tom Cruise is a sheer delight. His slow, meanderingly paced act as the indulgent rocker, who cannot seem to stay in his senses is simply stunning and different from anything he has done. Despite some good competition from others around, especially the perennially delightful Paul Giamatti, and the lovely Catherine Zeta Jones, Cruise, cruises along brilliantly.

The film will be of particular interest to the generation that grew up listening to song of bands like Guns N' Roses, Def Leppard, Foreigner, Journey, Poison and Europe among many other. The way some of their popular songs are used, misused and often mutilated, is simply delightful.

It is a film that ACP Vasant Dhoble must watch for it just might be the pill that will ease him up a bit.  

(This review has been written for the wire service, IANS)

Saturday, May 19, 2012

The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel – Exquisitely Exotic


Director: John Madden
Actors: Judi Dench, Tom Wilkinson, Bill Nighy, Maggie Smith, Dev Patel
Rating: 4/5

Is old age the wait for the inevitable? But this inevitable was staring even in youth! Why is it that we get tired the older we get - tired to try new things. And what if circumstances force us to do exactly that? Will we rediscover the zest for life or will we give up without a fight because we believe we’re too old to fight?

‘The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel’ (TBEMH) by 'Shakespeare in Love' director John Madden confronts these questions in a hilarious, adventurous, light-hearted and yet poignant way. It is one of the best ‘exotic’ films to have come into your theatres in a long time.
Life is all sad and gloomy in the end? Not quite, as our gang ultimately discover

Seven British retirees ‘outsource’ their retirement to a reasonably priced and exotic hotel in Jaipur, India. Here their dreams of final peaceful days are shattered as they find that the truth about this retirement home had been ‘photoshopped’.

Instead of leisure, they are confronted with their own pasts and prejudices and each is forced to discover the meaning of life, anew.

The first and most important thing you’ll notice is its incredible wit. The writing, based on a novel by Deborah Moggach is simply stunning with wit that is hilarious without being patronising. An old woman says: “I don’t even buy green bananas. I can’t plan so far ahead.” Another says “What I can’t pronounce, I don’t eat.” Yet another comments, “I’m your wife. Have we met?”

Lines like these pop at regular intervals invigorating the soul of a cineaste desperate for such intelligent dialogues in cinema.
"Iceberg! Right ahead!!" Oops... its only an overtaking truck. 

The focus of the film, and all its subplots, is clearly age and time. Time becomes a metaphor to entice viewers to look inside themselves and find their own relationship with time and age. Thus, it might be a film situated in the stories of ‘old’ people, in reality it is about all of us finding ourselves. It will have a resonance across ages.

The script is extremely intelligent and manages to find the common between India and Britain e.g. when Tom Wilkinson plays cricket with kids on the street. That scene is meant not just to bridge the gap between Britain and India, but also between age and youth.

It also makes a comment on many evils plaguing the county, like the existence of caste hierarchy and the opposition to homosexuality in a very staid and gentle manner.

The casting is a charm. If the world were not so preoccupied with youth and beauty, one would have called this one of the best ensemble cast ever.

And a casting coup it indeed is, not of stars in an ‘Avengers’ sort of way, but real actors who breathe so much life into what they play that they stop being the person they are but the part they play.

Almost every one of the cast, be it Judi Dench, Tom Wilkinson, Bill Nighy, Maggie Smith, or even our very own Lillette Dubey are spectacular in their roles.

The only ‘actor’ who irritates this impeccable ensemble is Dev Patel. However one guesses that as a new representative of ‘diaspora’ actors, no British or Hollywood film set in India can be ‘complete’ without him.

Besides the special effects laden films, ‘The Best Exotic…” is the type of beautiful little films with big hearts for whom big screens are made. Go watch it in one. You’ll have the fun, touching ride of your life.

(This review was written for and published by the wire service Indo-Asian News Service - IANS)